Skip to main content

on nature


A mind-opening book I read years ago prompted me to write this text, and more importantly, to think.

Oxana Timetova, in The History of Animals, mentioned that during the Middle Ages, animals were put on trial in courts.

Here is the most striking paragraph, appeals to me a lot:

''Secular courts generally hosted cases where individual domesticated animals were defendants,” or “when an animal had caused physical harm to a person or even led to someone’s death,” those animals were tried and punished. Meanwhile, “wild animal groups like swarms of vermin” or “animals that had caused public harm (typically by destroying crops intended for human consumption)” were usually under the jurisdiction of sharia (religious) courts. Among the individual animals put on trial were pigs, cows, bulls, horses, mules, oxen, goats, donkeys, and dogs. In sharia courts, more often the defendants were moles, mice, rats, snakes, birds, snails, wolves, locusts, caterpillars, termites, various insects and flies, other unspecified "vermin" even eels and dolphins were considered defendants (Girgen 2003: 99).

Although the defendants were unusual, proceedings in both sharia and secular courts were taken very seriously, with strict adherence to legal customs and formal procedures applicable to human defendants. Communities even hired lawyers out of their own pockets for accused animals, and these lawyers presented complex legal arguments in favor of the animal defendants. In criminal cases, animals were sometimes held in custody alongside human prisoners. Evidence was evaluated, and verdicts were announced as if the defendant were human. When it came time to carry out the sentence, often capital punishment, secular courts would call on a professional executioner, and payments were made just as they were in other executions (age).''

This pharagraph provokes me to think on our ontological ground in the world as humans, how we have mostly separated ourselves from animals, plants, and, more broadly, from nature.

We have witnessed wars, sieges, and invasions throughout history, always driven by the desire for “more.” In the light of modernism and capitalism, we continue this pattern by exploiting nature as if it were an endless resource to fulfill our development plans. When we address the climate crisis as an urgent matter, I realize that we still operate from an anthropocentric mindset, to only prolong our stay on this planet.

What we fail to acknowledge is that the material world around us, what we so often call 'nature' without considering our relationship to it, is not merely a resource to be consumed, but a living, dignified entity that embraces and includes us.  We must rethink our existence on this Earth, not as beings separate from or above nature, but as extensions of it. This crisis, as a breaking point, should urge us toward new transformations and fresh perspectives in thinking and acting not following the former patterns.

''In March 2017, the New Zealand parliament enacted the Te Awa Tupua Act which declared the Whanganui river a legal person with fundamental rights. This means the Te Awa Tupua will have its own legal identity with all the corresponding rights, duties and liabilities of a legal person.'' (EcoJurisprudence Project)

These thoughts brought me to the philosophy of Maurice Merleau-Ponty, which can indeed offer us a foundation for onthological-ethical thinking about how we must understand nature as something we are within. 


Touching other people, animals, plants, everything we see and don't see, knowing that this is what makes us who we are.
Knowing that;
Thinking from within,
Seeing the world like in a Cézanne painting, without separating form from color, where everything blends into everything else.
Always searching for another way of seeing.

will make our new world.









Comments